Review - Charles Dutoit, Nikolai Lugansky & Hong Kong Philharmonic Orchestra, Hong Kong Cultural Centre, 18 November 2017

Roman Carnival Overture (Berlioz)
Piano Concerto no. 3 (Rachmaninov)
Encore: Prelude op. 23 no. 7 (Rachmaninov)
The Song of the Nightingale (Stravinsky)
Daphnis and Chloe Suite no. 2 (Ravel)

Nikolai Lugansky (piano)
Charles Dutoit (conductor)
Hong Kong Philharmonic Orchestra

Despite an attractive programme with a reputable conductor and pianist, the performance was far from a success and even some shockingly disastrous moments. Though the problem was not apparent at first in the festive and lively Roman Carnival overture, which Kwan Sheung-fung played the cor anglais solo beautifully after an electrifying introduction by the strings. Yet Dutoit's conducting was rather square and not indicating the line, and let the orchestra to phrase the line on its own. Soon the playing lost focus and rather vertically looking. The strings produced a warm tone and Italianate in style, but too polite overall than carrying the dramatic urgency in mind. They were also sluggish and lacked the bite on the attacks until the winds gave a crushing entry at the time change. The brass fanfare added the wildness and intensity to the tone colour, which lacked before at the presto ending by merely being full and broad.

Compare to other works on the programme, Rachmaninov's third piano concerto is more symphonic and arguably the more familiar to the audience. A flowing start but already signs of untidiness among the orchestral playing. Lugansky preferred a rather swift tempo in the tranquil theme but Dutoit's indication on the pulse was rather random with his right hand, which seems confused the orchestra. Despite the piano solo was majestic, the thick descending passage did not stay together with the winds. Lugansky also placed a lot of weight in his left hand playing and rather cloudy on the pedal that produced a dense tone. The phrasing felt rather out of shape at the rhythmic tricky part and also some wrong notes on the piano playing. Yet the duet between the flute and oboe were played beautifully with a bell like tone. The recapitulation was relaxing and played at a soft dynamic but odd when Dutoit suddenly speed up the tempo to reach the coda.

The orchestral playing of the second movement introduction was uncertain, which Dutoit was unclear in his conducting and even at times followed the players' tempo. Lugansky's left hand was heavy on the touch again and created a dense colour on the sentimental theme that lacked contrast. Then the pianist and orchestra were dangerously out of synchronisation for few bars when Dutoit seems at lost. Despite Lugansky tried to hide the disaster by being very expressive on his part and possibly improvised, the music was structurally out of shape and randomly developed. Although a virtuosic and muscular start to the third movement on the piano, the orchestra was still lost and confused by Dutoit's conducting. Strangely enough everything got back together in the dream like section, but the concentration and focus were lost already with the slow tempo. Heavy handed playing at the heroic and exuberant passage, but tempo suddenly gone slow by half, and it was a surprise that everything finished together in the end. One was also amazed by the rather enthusiastic reception to such chaotic performance.

Luckily everything was back on track in the second half that Dutoit's conducting seems more in place even the orchestra was leading the direction. Percussions and winds made an explosive entry to Stravinsky's rather colourful score of the song of the Nightingale. The harmonic language imitated festive Chinese instruments but fragmented. Megan Sterling's flute solo carried the rhythmic energy by being crisp in her playing, but the music became abstract and moody as the dialogues of night music dominated. It sprang back to the excitement half way onward with the winds' energetic playing and kept the rhythmic momentum forward. Emperor's nightmarish vision was realised by the sudden cry on the strings and shapeless dances on the woodwind part. At coda it became even more mysterious with a grotesque slow march on the strings, but jazzy blue solo on the trumpet that sounded certain among the cloudy music that being built upon.

The soft blurry impression continued into the dreamy opening of Ravel's second ballet suite of Daphnis and Chloe. The calm image of ocean with ripples was tenderly realised, and one felt the vastness of sound when the strings built up the sunrise climax. Megan Sterling again gave a confident lead between the lyric expressive part and the energetic rhythmic driven section. The impressionistic sound landscape was played in a broad sense as waves but cloudy. All was clear up when the winds played the gallop wildly and explosive during the exuberant dance section. The orchestra had more bites in its playing finally that added to the desired dramatic intensity and became an energetic beast. It seems the leaner orchestral parts had the upper hand this evening and sentiments failed to excel as in the Rachmaninov.